Reviews
Don’t take our word for it, see what our current customers have to say
August 9, 2025
"Move over McLoons! Beats Red’s Eats! There’s a new “Best Lobster Roll” in Maine! Mainly? No, positively! Positivity the best lobster roll in Maine is at Mainely Seafood Company! Great? No. Incredible? No? Fabulous! Getting close, but still no. Mainely Seafood Company is clearly, and simply THE BEST! The only question is who’s number two. More pieces and bigger pieces of absolutely the most delicious lobster you’ll ever eat! Pinky promise! And if the lobster wasn’t why you have to (HAVE TO!) go to Mainely Seafood, their rolls alone would merit the drive! You can search all the boulangeries in France and you won’t find a roll even half as good as the rolls at Mainely Seafood, it’s as simple as 2 + 2 = 4! The best lobster + the best roll = the best lobster roll! Where? Mainely Seafood Company!"
August 9, 2025
"Excellent selection, always fresh- friendly staff and owner and the absolute best lobster roll around! If you haven’t gone in and tried it - run, don’t walk!"
August 9, 2025
"If you love fresh seafood, this place is a dream come true! The selection is incredible—everything from sweet scallops to fresh fish that tastes like it came straight off the boat. The quality is unmatched, and you can tell they take pride in offering only the best. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and always happy to give presentation recommendations. This is hands-down my go-to seafood market in Maine!"
August 9, 2025
"Great lobster roll! Lots of lobster. Toasted roll. Friendly service. Nice outdoor seating. Good Maine vibe. What more could you want?!! Loved it!! Thank you."
August 9, 2025
"couldn’t be more proud of Rod and’s Bonnie and the amazing seafood business they’ve built. Everything they sell is unbelievably fresh — the kind of quality you usually only find right off the boat. You can tell how much heart and hard work goes into every order, from the careful packaging to the friendly, professional service. I’ve watched them pour their passion into this company, and it shows in every bite. Not only are you getting incredible seafood, but you’re also supporting someone who truly cares about their customers. I recommend them to anyone I know traveling home!!"
August 9, 2025
"Excellent, fresh food and a big variety with better prices than other seafood establishments. Friendly staff and very personable owners!! Great atmosphere. The only place I will get my seafood from now on! Thank you Mainely Seafood, for the wonderful experience, you have a customer for life!"