Reviews
Don’t take our word for it, see what our current customers have to say
October 4, 2025
"A fine example of a Maine lobster roll: simple, loaded with lobster, all substance."
October 4, 2025
"Best lobster roll we have had in Maine. The reviews are accurate. We were so happy we stopped!"
October 3, 2025
"OMG! We are from the Midwest and had to see what all the “lobster roll” fuss was about. Now we know! We chose Mainley Seafood Company based on the excellent reviews about the seafood, bread it is served on and the portion size. We were delighted by the freshness and size. We got one lobster roll and one crab roll done Maine style. The light mayo added to the meal without overpowering the freshness of the seafood. The bread it is served on (no hotdog buns here) is light, buttery and perfectly toasted.
Rodney, the owner, greeted us when we walked in and made us feel welcomed. He answered all of our ”Midwestern” questions and brought our meals to the comfortable outdoor seating area when it was ready. Bonus! The inside of the storefront was immaculately clean!
Look no further when looking for a truly, mouthwatering meal."
October 2, 2025
"Best lobster roll ever! Not this shredded stuff I've had before - huge chunks of really tender lobster meat. Seamed like an entire lobster on the roll. Now I feel like I'm in Maine!"
September 29, 2025
"Stopped here on a whim while visiting Freeport. The lobster roll is no frills but excellent - hot buttered bun and a generous amount of lobster including a ton of claw meat. Would absolutely recommend"
September 26, 2025
"Hands down, a must stop!!! The worker/possible owner was so friendly and explained the menu if we had any questions. My husband had a lobster roll and I had the crabster and both were absolutely delicious! One of the best rolls we have had on our vacation! Highly recommend stopping here!"