Reviews
Don’t take our word for it, see what our current customers have to say
October 10, 2025
"Mainely Seafood Company is a fantastic spot for fresh and flavorful seafood! I had the lobster roll, and it was absolutely delicious—packed with tender, perfectly seasoned lobster on a soft, buttery roll. The portions were generous, and everything tasted incredibly fresh. The staff was friendly and welcoming, creating a great local atmosphere that made the meal even more enjoyable. A must-visit for anyone craving an authentic Maine lobster roll experience!"
October 6, 2025
"We did not originally see Mainely Seafood at the top of our quick Google search when we were pining for a lobster roll while strolling through Freeport. We went to a competitor who announced upon our sitting down to order that they were "out of lobster rolls." DISAPPOINTED!!!!!! So instead of pouting like babies we did another quick search and up popped Mainely. We hoofed it down to the Mainely and Rodney immediately smiled when he saw my Patriots' hat and we connected right off the bat. A few minutes later, Rodney came out and served us our two lobstah rolls and chips right at our table. One look and we knew we got it right. Stuffed to the gills but no mayo or anything else dripping off it...just as we would've expected given the stellar reviews.
Rodney and the family nail it! Don't waste your time hunting around Freeport or any other city in Maine for the BEST lobster roll on the planet. Go straight to Mainely. You can thank me after.
Michelle and Christopher Muise"
October 5, 2025
"A hidden gem! One of the best lobster rolls we’ve had on our trip across New England."
October 4, 2025
"A fine example of a Maine lobster roll: simple, loaded with lobster, all substance."
October 4, 2025
"Best lobster roll we have had in Maine. The reviews are accurate. We were so happy we stopped!"
October 3, 2025
"OMG! We are from the Midwest and had to see what all the “lobster roll” fuss was about. Now we know! We chose Mainley Seafood Company based on the excellent reviews about the seafood, bread it is served on and the portion size. We were delighted by the freshness and size. We got one lobster roll and one crab roll done Maine style. The light mayo added to the meal without overpowering the freshness of the seafood. The bread it is served on (no hotdog buns here) is light, buttery and perfectly toasted.
Rodney, the owner, greeted us when we walked in and made us feel welcomed. He answered all of our ”Midwestern” questions and brought our meals to the comfortable outdoor seating area when it was ready. Bonus! The inside of the storefront was immaculately clean!
Look no further when looking for a truly, mouthwatering meal."